cherry-studio/packages/ui/MIGRATION_STATUS.md

Cherry Studio UI Migration Plan

Overview

This document outlines the detailed plan for migrating Cherry Studio from antd + styled-components to shadcn/ui + Tailwind CSS. We will adopt a progressive migration strategy to ensure system stability and development efficiency, while gradually implementing UI refactoring in collaboration with UI designers.

Migration Strategy

Target Tech Stack

• UI Component Library: shadcn/ui (replacing antd and previously migrated HeroUI)
• Styling Solution: Tailwind CSS v4 (replacing styled-components)
• Design System: Custom CSS variable system (--cs-* namespace)
• Theme System: CSS variables + Tailwind CSS theme

Migration Principles

1. Backward Compatibility: Old components continue working until new components are fully available
2. Progressive Migration: Migrate components one by one to avoid large-scale rewrites
3. Feature Parity: Ensure new components have all the functionality of old components
4. Design Consistency: Follow new design system specifications (see README.md)
5. Performance Priority: Optimize bundle size and rendering performance
6. Designer Collaboration: Work with UI designers for gradual component encapsulation and UI optimization

Usage Example

// Import components from @cherrystudio/ui
import { Spinner, DividerWithText, InfoTooltip } from '@cherrystudio/ui'

// Use in components
function MyComponent() {
  return (
    <div>
      <Spinner size={24} />
      <DividerWithText text="Divider Text" />
      <InfoTooltip content="Tooltip message" />
    </div>
  )
}

Directory Structure

@packages/ui/
├── src/
│   ├── components/         # Main components directory
│   │   ├── primitives/     # Basic/primitive components (Avatar, ErrorBoundary, Selector, etc.)
│   │   │   └── shadcn-io/  # shadcn/ui components (dropzone, etc.)
│   │   ├── icons/          # Icon components (Icon, FileIcons, etc.)
│   │   └── composites/     # Composite components (CodeEditor, ListItem, etc.)
│   ├── hooks/              # Custom React Hooks
│   ├── styles/             # Global styles and CSS variables
│   ├── types/              # TypeScript type definitions
│   ├── utils/              # Utility functions
│   └── index.ts            # Main export file

Component Classification Guide

When submitting PRs, please place components in the correct directory based on their function:

• primitives: Basic and primitive UI elements, shadcn/ui components
  • Avatar: Avatar components
  • ErrorBoundary: Error boundary components
  • Selector: Selection components
  • shadcn-io/: Direct shadcn/ui components or adaptations
• icons: All icon-related components
  • Icon: Icon factory and basic icons
  • FileIcons: File-specific icons
  • Loading/spinner icons (SvgSpinners180Ring, ToolsCallingIcon, etc.)
• composites: Complex components made from multiple primitives
  • CodeEditor: Code editing components
  • ListItem: List item components
  • ThinkingEffect: Animation components
  • Form and interaction components (DraggableList, EditableNumber, etc.)

Component Extraction Criteria

Extraction Standards

1. Usage Frequency: Component is used in ≥ 3 places in the codebase
2. Future Reusability: Expected to be used in multiple scenarios in the future
3. Business Complexity: Component contains complex interaction logic or state management
4. Maintenance Cost: Centralized management can reduce maintenance overhead
5. Design Consistency: Components that require unified visual and interaction experience
6. Test Coverage: As common components, they facilitate unit test writing and maintenance

Extraction Principles

• Single Responsibility: Each component should only handle one clear function
• Highly Configurable: Provide flexible configuration options through props
• Backward Compatible: New versions maintain API backward compatibility
• Complete Documentation: Provide clear API documentation and usage examples
• Type Safety: Use TypeScript to ensure type safety

Cases Not Recommended for Extraction

• Simple display components used only on a single page
• Overly customized business logic components
• Components tightly coupled to specific data sources

Migration Steps

Phase	Status	Main Tasks	Description
Phase 1	✅ Completed	Design System Integration	• Converted design tokens from todocss.css to tokens.css with --cs-* namespace • Created theme.css mapping all design tokens to standard Tailwind classes • Extended Tailwind with semantic spacing (5xs~8xl) and radius (4xs~3xl) systems • Established two usage modes: full override and selective override • Cleaned up main package's conflicting Shadcn theme definitions
Phase 2	⏳ To Start	Component Migration and Optimization	• Filter components for migration based on extraction criteria • Remove antd dependencies, replace with shadcn/ui • Remove HeroUI dependencies, replace with shadcn/ui • Remove styled-components, replace with Tailwind CSS + design system variables • Optimize component APIs and type definitions
Phase 3	⏳ To Start	UI Refactoring and Optimization	• Gradually implement UI refactoring with UI designers • Ensure visual consistency and user experience • Performance optimization and code quality improvement

Notes

1. Do NOT migrate components with these dependencies (can be migrated after decoupling):

   • window.api calls
   • Redux (useSelector, useDispatch, etc.)
   • Other external data sources

2. Can migrate but need decoupling later:

   • Components using i18n (change i18n to props)
   • Components using antd (replace with shadcn/ui later)
   • Components using HeroUI (replace with shadcn/ui later)

3. Submission Guidelines:

   • Each PR should focus on one category of components
   • Ensure all migrated components are exported
   • Follow component extraction criteria, only migrate qualified components

Design System Integration

CSS Variable System

• All design tokens use --cs-* namespace (e.g., --cs-primary, --cs-red-500)
• Complete color palette: 17 colors × 11 shades each
• Semantic spacing system: 5xs through 8xl (16 levels)
• Semantic radius system: 4xs through 3xl plus round (11 levels)
• Full light/dark mode support
• See README.md for usage documentation

Migration Priority Adjustment

1. High Priority: Basic components (buttons, inputs, tags, etc.)
2. Medium Priority: Display components (cards, lists, tables, etc.)
3. Low Priority: Composite components and business-coupled components

UI Designer Collaboration

• All component designs need confirmation from UI designers
• Gradually implement UI refactoring to maintain visual consistency
• New components must comply with design system specifications